Property Management Blog

Self Managing vs Hiring Property Management: Which Is Right for You?

Self Managing vs Hiring Property Management: Which Is Right for You?

Owning and managing an investment property or multiple rental properties can be a rewarding but challenging endeavor. When you own a rental property, you are responsible for handling rental payments, drafting the rental agreement, and addressing various property issues that may arise.

Whether you own one or many properties, understanding how many you can efficiently manage will determine whether self-management is feasible or whether you need to hire professional help.

As a property owner, deciding whether to self-manage your rental properties or hire a property management company is crucial to the success of your rental business. This decision can significantly affect your cash flow, property management tasks, tenant satisfaction, and overall financial performance.

Let’s explore both approaches to help you make an informed decision!

Self Managing Rental Properties

Self-managing rental properties is an attractive option for property owners seeking potential cost savings. By avoiding property management fees, which are a percentage of the monthly rent, you can directly improve your cash flow. 

Self-managing your property also allows you to completely control the rent price, tenant selection, and day-to-day operations of your rental property.

One primary advantage of self-managing your rental properties is your direct involvement. As the property owner, you handle all property management tasks, including tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance requests, and even tenant disputes.

By personally handling these responsibilities, you gain a hands-on understanding of your rental property’s condition, tenant behavior, and financial management, leading to greater insights into your rental property’s performance.

Disadvantages of Self-Management

However, self-management has its challenges. Managing a rental property is often time-consuming, especially when managing multiple properties. Maintenance issues, tenant disputes, and the eviction process can quickly consume your time and energy.

Additionally, understanding fair housing laws, landlord tenant laws, and local laws is essential for legal compliance. Failure to comply can lead to legal ramifications, lease violations, and even financial penalties.

Self-managing might become overwhelming for real estate investors who own multiple properties, making it difficult to maintain quality tenant relationships and screen tenants effectively.

The more properties you own, the more time-consuming it becomes to address tenant needs, collect rent, handle property damage, and manage tenant selection.

Hiring a Property Management Company

On the contrary, hiring a property management company offers several benefits, especially for property owners who want to scale their portfolio or reduce their involvement in day-to-day operations.

A professional property manager takes on all aspects of rental property management, including tenant screening, maintenance requests, rent collection, finding good renters' insurance, and ensuring compliance with local laws and fair housing regulations.

Hiring a property manager can lead to quality tenants through more rigorous screening processes. Experienced property managers understand how to identify responsible tenants, minimizing the risk of property damage, late payments, and tenant disputes. 

Additionally, property managers handle financial management, ensuring rent is collected on time and the property’s cash flow is optimized.

While hiring a management company does come with a monthly fee, the potential cost savings in terms of time, stress, and legal compliance may outweigh the expense. 

For example, a property management company can help navigate the eviction process, reducing the risk of extended vacancy periods. They also have experience setting the optimal rent price, which helps maximize rental income while maintaining tenant satisfaction.

The Verdict

Ultimately, the choice between self-managing or hiring a property management company depends on your individual circumstances. For property owners with the time, knowledge, and desire for direct involvement, DIY property management can help them save money.

However, for those with multiple properties, limited time, or less experience managing tenants and legal compliance, hiring a professional property manager may be the better option to ensure long-term success.

Take the stress out of managing your rental property. Let our expert team handle everything—from tenant screening to rent collection—so you can enjoy hassle-free property ownership. Contact us today!

Additional Resources

The 10 Deadly Sins to a Wisconsin Lease Rental Agreement. Rental Housing Lease Agreement Violations

Finding the Perfect Place: A Guide to Renting Houses and Apartments Near UWEC

Back